4 Best Collection Of Colgate Crib Mattress Review

All mattresses look almost the same on the outside and that is why it is hard to decide what to buy. What matters is the inside of the mattress and that is where all the mattresses differ. You will be overwhelmed by the number of options. But remember, quality can never be compromised.

It is a piece of friendly advice to do your research before buying a crib mattress because the crib is the place where your infant spends most of his time. To help you in the search for a perfect crib mattress, I have prepared you a Colgate crib mattress review.

Do you want your baby to sleep comfortably? Or as a new parent, you feel that your baby’s sleeping hours are not enough, and he remains irritated for most of the day. If you relate to this, then let me tell you the reason for all this.

The reason is very simple and lies inside your home. It is in your baby’s nursery. It is the mattress your baby sleeps on. Yeah, that is the culprit. One wrong choice of mattress can cost you your baby’s health in the long run.

Importance of good sleep

Sleep is a key factor in growth. You need to cope up with all the demands of your child in the initial years. Primarily because these years are crucial for growth. If all the demands are not fulfilled, your child may lack physical and mental growth.

To ensure perfect sleep for your baby, you need Colgate dual sleep system crib mattress. It is a quality product and the investment benefit you in the long run even when your infant grows up. Most of the products in this article are of dual-use so that you make a smart investment.

Colgate crib mattress when to flip

You can flip a dual mattress after referring it to your paediatrician. Consumers of this mattress have reported increased comfortable sleeping hours for their babies.  According to research, 12-16 hours of sleep per day in the period of infancy is considered adequate. Similarly, 11-14 hours is recommended in the toddler phase.

Such mattresses are manufactured with great care and love. Colgate makes your child’s comfort their top priority and I think you should invest in such brands that are very observant of your child’s needs.

When these requirements are met, the baby brain and body show rapid development.

How to clean Colgate crib mattress

Regular cleaning of the mattress is also necessary for your baby’s health. You can use a vacuum for very basic cleaning once or twice a week. For a detailed one, you can even use the scrubbing method by mixing baby-friendly detergent with water and scrub it on the mattress.

Now let us jump into the list.

colgate crib mattress review

Comparison Table of Colgate Crib Mattress Review

Product ImageProduct NameProduct Information
Eco Classica III
  • Product Dimensions: 52 x 27.75 x 6 inches
  • Material Type: Cotton Foam
  • Features: 2- stage dual-firmness, waterproof
  • Item Weight: 9.44 pounds
  • Greenguard Gold Certified: Yes
Colgate Mini-Crib Mattress
  • Product Dimensions: 24 x 38.5 x 3 inches
  • Material Type: Memory Foam
  • Features: 3" thickness for extra plush comfort, waterproof
  • Item Weight: 2.8 pounds
  • Greenguard Gold Certified: Yes
Colgate 2-N-1 Innerspring Crib Mattress
  • Product Dimensions: 52 x 27.75 x 6 inches
  • Material Type: Innerspring
  • Features: 2- stage dual-firmness, waterproof & breathable
  • Item Weight: 20 Pounds
  • JPMA Certified: Yes
Colgate Classica I Crib Mattress
  • Product Dimensions: 51.63 x 27.25 x 5 inches
  • Material Type: Foam Construction
  • Features: 5" thick mattress, waterproof & breathable
  • Item Weight: 8 Pounds
  • JPMA Certified: Yes


  1. Eco Classica III
  2. Colgate Mini-Crib Mattress
  3. Colgate 2-N-1 Innerspring Crib Mattress
  4. Colgate Classica I Crib Mattress

Best Collection of Colgate Crib Mattress Review

1. Eco Classica III

My top favourite for the category of crib mattresses is Eco Classica III. It is an upgraded Colgate Classica III crib mattress. This one is an eco-friendly and healthier variant of the Classica series.

●      Design

Looking at the product, you can easily deduce that it is a perfect choice and a perfect fit for most of the standard cribs. The edges are curved perfectly to fit in easily.

The use of good quality bed covers enhances the comfort provided by the mattress. The topmost cover is the water-proof cover. The next layer is made of organic cotton. Under that is a layer of flammability barrier that ensures safety.

●      Features

What I like most about this product is that it is a dual mattress. One side is the infant side which is designed specifically to comply with the needs of infancy. It is made of firmer plant-oil based foam which makes t strong enough to support the infant.

The other side is the toddler side. It is made of eco-friendly foam which is less firm than the other side. This ensures that the toddler is provided with the required comfort and easement.

The mattress comes with various certifications such as GREENGUARD Gold and CertiPUR-US. It is also compliant with CPSIA standards. This makes the product very reliable and trustworthy.

The mattress comes in hassle-free packaging and is very easy to set up. Changing sheets and frequent cleaning is not a big task because of the products are lightweight. 

●      Protection

What makes it stand the test of time is the water-proof cover that comes with the mattress. It is safe if your baby’s skin comes in contact with this cover because it is soft and is made of organic cotton.

This cover protects the mattress and makes it more repellent to stains but still, zero stains are never guaranteed.

●      Pros & Cons

  • Includes a water-proof cover
  • Durable
  • Easy to move
  • Usable in the long run
  • Have inverted seams
  • Not 100% organic

2. Colgate Mini-Crib Mattress

If you have a mini crib, do not worry. You can have Colgate mini crib mattress for your child. Colgate mattress also comes in mini size apart from the standard size. to fit in a greater number of cribs.

●      Design

This product has the lightest weight on the list. It is 2.8-pounds in weight and can still carry up to 60 pounds. This makes it portable and you can easily take it out of the crib for cleaning and reorganization. You can even take it with you for a stay-over or a trip.

This offer is value for money as this product contains all the desirable features in lighter weight and smaller packaging.

●      Features

What makes this product a must-have is its eco-friendly nature which is amazing because products in such a cheap price range usually do not offer that. It is made of eco-foam and plant-based oils.

Colgate has successfully provided what every parent wants in a very budget-friendly price range. This product is hypoallergenic. Even if your child is super sensitive, his skin will not react to this mattress.

The cloth binding on the outside is very strong to support the child. At the same time, its 3-inch thickness makes it comfortable for the baby. It perfectly aligns with infant and toddler needs without even being an actual dual mattress.

It has all the required US certifications, so you need not worry about reliability. It complies well with all the international standards so you can invest without a doubt. Also, the Certi-PUR US certification ensures quality along with safety. 

●      Protection

The strong cloth binding seams prevent any stray threads at the ends which may risk your child’s life. The water-proof cover is made of Damask cloth which is not only repellent to liquid penetration but also extremely flexible and resists creases.

Now you do not have to worry about diaper leaks. If you become slightly more conscious, you can even leave your kid diaper-free for some hours on this mattress. It is very essential to let the skin breathe.

●      Pros & Cons

  • Affordable price
  • Firmness balanced with comfort
  • No coils
  • Single-sided mattress

3. Colgate 2-N-1 Innerspring Crib Mattress

If you are looking for a mattress with springs, this product is for you. A spring mattress increases the support provided, hence it is good for infant years.

●      Design

The spring coils used in the manufacture of this product are high-quality ones. There is a total of 135 coils made of thick 13.5-Gauge tempered steel. The border has 9-Gauge steel rods that support the entire unit and make it sturdy.

It is certified by all the required associations mentioned in the above products. All-natural latex is used in the manufacture of this product, so it is safe to say that it is Eco-friendly. I have tried to add as many eco-friendly options as possible.

●      Features

The layer around the spring coils is what makes this mattress different and innovative from others. This layer is made up of an insulator pad which consists of coconut shell husks. Supportive cushioning layers are also added with the pads. These layers are made of natural cotton.

Above these layers, there is another triple-layer of protection. The product is engineered wonderfully. It has multiple side vents that increase the airflow across the mattress.

The foam is made of Polyurethane. This material is non-allergenic and completely safe for the baby. Colgate crib mattress 2 in 1 is perfectly aligned with both infant and toddler needs. It has both strength and comfort.

You might need some help in setting up this product as it is a bit heavier than other options on the list. But since it is a spring mattress, so the weight is comparatively lighter than other spring mattress options.

●      Protection

Almost all the products on the list have some sort of waterproof covering. But they do differ in their material and degree of being waterproof. In this mattress, the water-proof covering is made of vinyl which is tear-resistant and has a nylon triple-layer.

The spring layer protects the product from shock damage. In innerspring mattresses, you can either have a quantity of spring or quality. But this mattress offers both. With such features, it is not just a 2 in 1 product, it is an all-rounder.

●      Pros & Cons

  • Good fitting
  • High-quality springs
  • Does not wear out for years
  • Does not bend to accommodate bed cover change

4. Colgate Classica I Crib Mattress

If you want a lightweight option yet you cannot compromise on strength and durability, then this option is for you.

●      Design

This 5-inch-thick product is exactly what most of you out there are looking for. Colgate has mastered the art of balancing strength and comfort. So is this product. It is equally firm and comfortable.

This one is a bit different from other products as it has square edges. But still, there is no problem in the fitting of the mattress into the crib or a toddler bed. It has strong cloth binding seams.

●      Features

This product has stood the test of time and after being reviewed by several reviewers, it is still one of the favourites. One of America’s top baby gear magazines, Baby Bargains has been recommending this mattress for the past 15 years. It is so far the best Colgate crib mattress.

It comes in a simple white colour. The design fulfils all the requirements of infancy. As I have already mentioned, infants have very sensitive skin. But this hypo-allergenic mattress is perfect for them as it reduces the risk of allergies.

Moreover, it has eyelet vents on the border which ensure ventilation. Even if your mattress does not dry up completely before placing back into the crib, there will be no mould build-up due to good ventilation.

With a 51.63-inch length and 27.25 inches width, this mattress is firmer than any of its competitors. A firm mattress makes the infant sleep faster. A mattress that is too firm for you might be perfect for your infant. So, the needs of two different bodies should not be compared.

●      Protection

The water-proof cover made of vinyl is a good liquid repellent. It is a triple layer enforced vinyl cover which is resistant to tears. Such a cover goes with you in the long run. For added protection, you can always add another water-proof cover.

Cleaning for this mattress is more simplified than ever. You can wipe clean with your regular mild soap.

●      Pros & Cons

  • Extremely portable
  • Easy changing of bed covers
  • Durable
  • Does not degas in the long run
  • Maybe more firm for some consumers


This article has been brought to you after a lot of research on the Colgate brand. A mattress is something that you do not buy every day, and many people do not know what to look for in one. Also, there are quite a lot of options online and in local stores.

So, I have written this Colgate crib mattress review for you to help you in this matter. I hope now you know what exactly you need to buy. It is advisable to buy baby gear online rather than going to a local store because there are better deals online.

For a little tip, I would say that always measure your crib from inside before placing the order. It might seem obvious, but most people tend to ignore or forget this one.

Also, keep your mattress empty on the inside except for a bed cover. Yeah, I know all those toys and blankets look very fancy, but they increase the chance of sudden death by choking or strangling.

I hope my research and recommendations will facilitate you. Do not forget to share this article with your friends and family.

Do you need guidance about purchasing organic crib mattresses then check out this article, Your Guide to Purchasing an Organic Crib Mattress?

Scroll to Top